Opening streets between gated urbanizations. Simulation of an intermediate road network for the peri-urban territory of Mendoza, Argentina

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26754/ojs_zarch/zarch.20242310454

Keywords:

street, gated urbanization, Mendoza, grid, network analysis, peri-urban territory

Abstract

Gated communities are now one of the common forms in the expansion of Latin American cities. In Greater Mendoza area (Argentina), there are about 384. Their size and aggregation are causing the saturation of part of the peri-urban territory, thus fostering a landscape marked by large enclosures with specific accesses and a road structure with large block sizes and roads. This work considers that this is pathological for the future of peri-urban fabrics. A careful reading of their size and relative position demonstrates the dominance of laissez-faire, since the current regulations excessively allow possible locations. However, the study focuses on the absence of active thinking about the streets that structure the territory. As if it were an urban laboratory, a possible proposal for a new grid of intermediate streets is presented, which meets two purposes: (1) ensuring the urban quality of territories in extension through gated communities and (2) enhancing the existing grid. The work uses network analysis to evaluate the achievement of these two objectives, observing the proposal's capacity to multiply intermediate streets, to expand pre-existing local centralities, to promote the proliferation of new intersections, and to obtain a fine-grained block structure that safeguards peri-urban quality.

Display downloads

Author Biographies

  • Álvaro Clua, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya

    Álvaro Clua, Barcelona 1988. Is an architect (ETSAB, 2012) and holds a Ph.D. in Architecture (UPC 2017). He is a member of the Barcelona Urbanism Laboratory and a Professor of Urbanism at ETSABarcelona. Clua teaches in the University of Virginia – Barcelona Program since 2017 and has been a guest lecturer at the Master in Strategic Planning (KADK, 2018/2024). His research on infrastructural landscapes, urban projects, network analysis, and advanced cartographies has been published in journals like Planning Perspectives, Journal of Urban Design, VLC Arquitectura, and Journal of Urban History. He authored books such as Urban Backgrounds (2023), Calles a medida (UNCUYO-UPC, 2022), Edge Housing (2020), and Remix: Urban Production Landscapes (2019), and contributed chapters to Urbanistic Projects: Next Generational Paths (2024) and ArkDes Research Symposium on Architectural History (2020). Clua has been developing urban design works for entities like the Metropolitan Area of Barcelona or Mendoza, regional and local administrations, and has co-authored several award-winning proposals in national and international competitions. More information: www.alvaroclua.com

  • Josep Parcerisa, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya

    Barcelona, 1956. Architect (ETSAB 1981), Phd. Architect (UPC 1991) and Full Professor of Urbanism (2007). Director of the Barcelona Urbanism Laboratory. Cofounder of UR- UrbanismoRevista (1985-1992) and D’UR. He teaches undergraduate and master's degrees at ETSAB. He carries out consulting work in Barcelona, Medellín, Santiago de Chile, Mendoza and urban projects and planning in Valladolid, Cartagena, Maó, Salou and in Barcelona’s metropolitan suburbs. Has published in Lotus international, Perspecta, Quaderns and Phalaris. The construction of the metropolitan reality 1975-2015, exhibition (GSD Harvard, MA, 2016). Books: El canon republicano y la distancia cincomil (PUC Chile, 2015) with J.Rosas; Barcelona. 20th Century Urbanism (Marge Books, 2014); Forma urbis. Cinco ciudades bajo sospecha (LUB-UPC Barcelona, 2012); “Progetto urbano e urbanistica delle città” in Di cosa parliamo quando parliamo di urbanistica (Meltemi ed. Roma, 2006); Metro. Metropolitan galaxies (EdicionsUPC, 2002) and La ciudad no es una hoja en blanco (PUC Chile, 2000), both with M.Rubert.

  • Josemaría Silvestro, Universidad Nacional de Cuyo

    José María Silvestro, born on 11th November 1966 in Villa Mercedes, San Luis, Argentina, is an urban architect with a distinguished academic career. He graduated as an Urban Architect from the Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism at the National University of San Juan in 1996. Subsequently, he completed his Doctorate in Architecture at the Polytechnic University of Catalonia in Barcelona in 2006. Since 3rd March 2013, he has been serving as a Full Professor through a competition at the Faculty of Engineering of the National University of Cuyo in Mendoza, Argentina. He has made significant contributions to the field of architecture with publications such as "Tailored Streets: A Practice of Urban Planning in Mendoza" and "Urban Vitality in the Suburb". His roles as Project Director are noteworthy, as seen in projects like "West Coast Park: Malargüe 2030" and the "Road Forecast Plan for the Metropolitan Area of Mendoza".

References

Barajas, Luis Felipe Cabrales. “Urbanizaciones cerradas en Latinoamérica”. Ería, no 63 (2004): 53–57.

Beltrán, Gastón, y Mariana Heredia. “La emergencia de los barrios privados en Buenos Aires”. Apuntes de Investigación del CECYP 6, no 8 (2002): 118–36.

Bisbal, Ignacio, y Maria Oliver. “Fragmentación y homogeneidad en la ciudad media latinoamericana: baja densidad y monofuncionalidad en el crecimiento residencial reciente del Gran Mendoza”. En Ciudad y formas urbanas. Perspectivas transversales, 23–31. Zaragoza, 2018.

Borsdorf, Axel. “Hacia la ciudad fragmentada. Tempranas estructuras segregadas en la ciudad latinoamericana”. Scripta Nova 7, no 146 (2003).

Busquets, Joan, Dingliang Yang, y Michael Keller. Ciudad regular: manual para diseñar mallas y tramas urbanas. Book. Harvard: ORO Editions, 2020.

Carter, Harold. The study of urban geography. London: Edward Arnold, 1972.

De Solà-Morales, Manuel. Ciutats, cantonades / Villes, carrefours. Barcelona: Lunwerg / Fòrum Barcelona, 2004.

Engelman, Anabella, y Pehuén Barzola Elizagaray. “Propuesta para el estudio de urbanizaciones cerradas en Latinoamérica: el caso del enclave residencial de elite ‘Mendoza Norte Country Club’, Mendoza, Argentina”. Boletín de Estudios Geográficos, 2021.

Enríquez Acosta, Jesús Ángel. “Ciudad de muros: Socialización y tipología de las urbanizaciones cerradas en Tijuana”. Frontera norte 19, no 38 (2007): 127–56.

Font Arellano, Antonio. L’explosió de la ciutat: morfologies, mirades i mocions sobre les transformacions territorials recents en les regions urbanes de l’Europa Meridional. Barcelona: Col·legi d’Arquitectes de Catalunya, 2004.

Gassull, Virginia M. “Segregación de barrios populares en ciudades intermedias. Área Metropolitana de Mendoza, Argentina.” Revista F@ro, no 30 (2019): 41–62.

Gómez Ordóñez, José Luis. Una medida de accesibilidad: aplicación a la comarca de Barcelona. Barcelona: Laboratori d’Urbanisme de Barcelona, 1971.

Haggett, Peter. Network Analysis in Geography. London: Edward Arnold, 1969.

Hermelin, Michel, Alejandro Echeverri, y Jorge Giraldo, eds. Medellín: medio ambiente urbanismo y sociedad. Medellín: EAFIT, 2010.

Hidalgo, Rodrigo. “De los pequeños condominios a la ciudad vallada: las urbanizaciones cerradas y la nueva geografía social en Santiago de Chile (1990-2000)”. EURE (Santiago) 30, no 91 (2004): 29–52. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4067/S0250-71612004009100003

Hillier, B, A Penn, J Hanson, T Grajewski, y J Xu. “Natural movement: or, configuration and attraction in urban pedestrian movement”. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 20, no 1 (1993): 29–66. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1068/b200029

Hillier, Bill, Tao Yang, y Alasdair Turner. “Normalising least angle choice in Depthmap and it opens up new perspectives on the global and local analysis of city space”. Journal of Space Syntax 3, no 2 (2012): 155–93.

Indovina, Francesco. La città diffusa. Venezia: Istituto Universitario di Architettura di Venezia, 1990.

Janoschka, Michael. “El nuevo modelo de la ciudad latinoamericana: fragmentación y privatización”. EURE (Santiago) 28, no 85 (2002). DOI: https://doi.org/10.4067/S0250-71612002008500002

Karimi, Kayvan. “A configurational approach to analytical urban design: ‘space syntax’ methodology”. Urban Design International 17, no 4 (2012): 297–318. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/udi.2012.19

Mesa, Alejandro, y Cecilia Giusso. “Modelos de urbanización en tierras de alta vulnerabilidad ambiental: Análisis de la ocupación de la periferia del Área Metropolitana de Mendoza”. Cuaderno Urbano, 2014. DOI: https://doi.org/10.30972/crn.1616191

Molina, Alberto. Como una gran pecera. Mendoza: EDIUNC, 2013.

Palmer, Montserrat, Patricio Gross, y Óscar Ortega. “La vivienda social chilena 1900/1950”. Revista CA, Documento. Reseña de la vivienda social en Chile, 1988.

Parcerisa, Josep. Forma urbis: cinco ciudades bajo sospecha. Barcelona: Laboratori d’Urbanisme de Barcelona, 2012.

Parcerisa, Josep, Josemaría Silvestro, y Álvaro Clua. Calles a medida. Una experiencia de urbanismo urbano en Mendoza. Mendoza: Universidad de Cuyo. Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, 2022.

Pereira, Rafael H. M., Frederico R. B. Holanda, Valério A. S. Medeiros, y Ana P. Barros. “The Use of Space Syntax in Urban Transport Analysis: Limits and Potentials”. Brasília: Institute for Applied Economic Research, 2015.

Roitman, Sonia. “Barrios cerrados y segregación social urbana”. Scripta Nova, 2003.

Roitman, Sonia. “Transformaciones urbanas en los ´90: los barrios cerrados del Area Metropolitana de Mendoza”. En IV Jornadas de Sociología. Buenos Aires: Universidad de Buenos Aires, 2000.

Schapira, Marie-France Prévot. “Fragmentación espacial y social: conceptos y realidades”. Perfiles Latinoamericanos 9, no 19 (2001): 33–56.

Sennett, Richard. The uses of disorder. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1970.

Vergara, Francisco, y Montserrat Palmer. El lote 9x18 en la encrucijada habitacional de hoy. PUC Chile, 1990.

Downloads

Published

2024-12-26

Issue

Section

Topic papers

How to Cite

Clua, Álvaro, Parcerisa, J., & Silvestro, J. (2024). Opening streets between gated urbanizations. Simulation of an intermediate road network for the peri-urban territory of Mendoza, Argentina. ZARCH. Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies in Architecture and Urbanism, 23, 72-87. https://doi.org/10.26754/ojs_zarch/zarch.20242310454
Received 2024-04-15
Accepted 2024-10-08
Published 2024-12-26